Fact Check Analysis: Does Rain Truly Help Wildfires or Trigger New Hazards?

This fact-checking request was submitted by one of our subscribers! Reminder: You too can submit your own fact-checking requests for free through the DBUNK app. We’ll investigate and publish the results to help bring you clarity in today’s noisy media environment.

Preliminary Review

On January 26, 2025, an article titled “Los Angeles Faces Risk of Mudslides With the Arrival of Rain” was published by Amy Graff on The New York Times. The content revolves around an upcoming forecast of moderate rains in Los Angeles County and its effects on wildfire-scarred landscapes. The article extensively covers issues of potential flooding, mudslides, and even the impact of rain on firefighting efforts. However, does the article present the situation factually or leave important points misrepresented or missing? Let’s dive in.

Fact Check Analysis

Misinformation: While the article suggests that light to moderate rain will provide a “much-needed soaking” to benefit firefighting crews, it omits the complexities of how rain affects wildfire-prone environments. The simplistic framing here risks misleading readers. Rain can indeed help extinguish wildfires by increasing soil moisture and reducing dry conditions, but in areas already burned, it often harms more than helps. In wildfire-scarred zones, heavy rain loosens topsoil, causing debris flows and potentially deadly mudslides. This nuance is not clearly stated in the article, giving a false impression of uniform benefits.

Missing Context: The article briefly mentions a 20% chance of debris flows “damaging roads and structures” in certain areas, but fails to provide important historical data about how such mudslides have caused severe destruction in Southern California in previous years. For instance, the 2018 Montecito mudslides—caused by post-wildfire rain—led to 23 fatalities and widespread damage. Referencing such events would have provided critical context for readers to understand the real risks.

Furthermore, a closer review reveals another major omission. The article neglects to mention the role of hydrophobic soil in post-fire areas. When wildfires burn vegetation, they create a waxy layer on the soil that repels water, exacerbating runoff during heavy rain. This drastically increases the likelihood of flash floods and mudslides, yet the article omits these specifics, leaving readers with an incomplete picture.

User Question Answered

Question: Does the rain actually help with wildfires, or does it create more problems with all this debris and flooding afterward?

Answer: The rain’s effects can go both ways depending on the intensity and the condition of the affected areas. Moderate rain in unburned areas or areas with light vegetation will certainly help control and suppress wildfire outbreaks. However, in areas already scarred by fires, rain often creates more problems than solutions. Without vegetation to stabilize hillsides, rain can trigger flash floods and mudslides, worsened by hydrophobic soil that forms after fires. These cascading issues, like washed-out roads or damaged communities, require awareness and preparation.

Additional Observations

While Krisan Lund, a meteorologist, is quoted urging caution and preparation for debris flows, the lack of detailed data in her warnings reduces their impact. The article could have bolstered her claims with concrete historical examples or scientific details to better inform the public about their level of risk.

Want to eliminate the confusion? Download the DBUNK app to get clear, fact-based answers whenever a media claim leaves you with more questions than answers.

Conclusion

The New York Times article rests on a solid foundation of weather predictions and expert commentary regarding imminent dangers from rain in wildfire zones. However, by glossing over key factors like soil hydrophobicity, historical disasters, and the complexities of firefighting during heavy rains, it ultimately provides an incomplete and, at times, misleading analysis. The dynamic between rain, fires, and the aftermath deserves more in-depth exploration.

If this article left you questioning its claims, you’re not alone. Join the conversation by following us on social media or by downloading our app. Streamlined, unbiased fact-checking is just a tap away!

Read the original article here: Los Angeles Faces Risk of Mudslides With the Arrival of Rain