One of our subscribers submitted a fact-check request about an article published by The Associated Press on February 27, 2025, titled “How many hostages are left in Gaza?” The article attempts to summarize the status of hostages still in Gaza after an agreed-upon exchange between Hamas and Israel. However, we found key issues with missing context and a lack of clarity regarding the negotiations and Israel’s position.
What’s Missing?
While the article provides general statistics, it does not acknowledge the complexities behind why all hostages have not been freed. The report states that the current exchange was the “last exchange planned under the first phase of the ceasefire,” but offers no explanation as to why complete hostage releases were not secured.
One of the major points that readers may have expected to be addressed is how Israeli leadership previously issued warnings that Hamas would face extreme consequences if hostages were not freed. The phrase “there was hell to pay” was widely used in media coverage and statements by Israeli officials. However, no explanation is provided for why Israel has not yet rescued all captives, nor is there insight into why Hamas is withholding certain individuals.
Casualty Figures and Conflicting Data
The article cites Gaza’s Health Ministry’s claim that more than 48,000 Palestinians have been killed, yet fails to address a major reporting flaw: the ministry does not separate civilian and combatant deaths in its figures. This omission is frequently pointed out by analysts who argue that the actual number of civilian casualties could be different from the total reported deaths, given military operations targeting Hamas fighters.
Additionally, other estimates from independent sources, including the United Nations, often provide varying figures. Without this clarification, the number presented in the article risks being misinterpreted as universally accepted, when it is highly contested.
Why Hasn’t Israel Rescued All Hostages?
Many are questioning why Israel has not been able to retrieve all hostages if the military is one of the most advanced in the world. Large-scale hostage rescues are highly challenging, particularly in an urban conflict zone like Gaza. The number of remaining hostages, which includes both living and deceased individuals, presents another challenge in negotiations.
Furthermore, Hamas is known for keeping hostages in hidden tunnels, utilizing civilian areas as shields, and leveraging captives for tactical purposes. Previous Israeli military operations conducted to rescue hostages resulted in dangerous confrontations, increasing the risk to both soldiers and hostages alike. The article does not provide this necessary context, leaving readers to wonder why the process has not been faster or all-encompassing.
Final Verdict
The article provides a general overview of hostages but lacks key details that would help explain unanswered questions. The omission of Israel’s prior warnings, Hamas’s strategic use of hostages, and the challenges of large-scale rescues creates confusion. Additionally, figures on Palestinian casualties were presented without qualification, making it difficult for readers to assess the accuracy of those numbers.
For those who want accurate, unbiased news that includes full context, download the DBUNK app today and eliminate research hours for good.
