Did Trump Shut Down All Student Loan Repayment Plans?
The recent CNBC article reported that the American Federation of Teachers (AFT) is suing the Department of Education for halting applications to student loan repayment plans. However, a user asked whether all loan repayment programs were impacted or if this primarily concerned the Biden-backed SAVE plan. We fact-checked the article for accuracy, context, and potential misrepresentation.
Understanding the Student Loan Policy Shift
Income-driven repayment (IDR) plans were introduced in the 1990s to make monthly student loan payments more manageable. In 2023, the Biden administration launched the SAVE plan, an enhanced version of IDR. However, legal challenges led to a federal appeals court blocking SAVE in early 2025, prompting the Trump administration to suspend IDR applications temporarily. This dispute over policy interpretation sparked the AFT lawsuit.
Fact-Checking Key Claims
Claim #1: The Trump administration shut down all student loan repayment plans.
The article states that the Trump administration “shut down access to affordable repayment plans” for millions of borrowers. However, official statements from the Department of Education clarify that the administration paused IDR applications due to a court ruling blocking the SAVE plan. The department anticipates reopening applications soon. While this move affects borrowers, it does not permanently end all IDR programs.
Claim #2: The Biden-backed SAVE plan was the primary cause of the suspension.
The Education Department’s website cites an 8th Circuit Court ruling that blocked SAVE, which prompted the temporary halt of IDR applications. The administration is revising its forms to comply with the legal decision, confirming that the SAVE ruling directly influenced the pause. However, AFT claims the administration could have kept other IDR options open. This demonstrates a legal gray area rather than an outright shutdown.
Claim #3: The Trump administration is playing politics with student loans.
The article includes a quote from the Student Borrower Protection Center suggesting political motivations behind the pause in applications. However, there is no direct evidence cited in the article proving political intent. The administration’s stated reasoning for the suspension revolves around legal obstacles rather than a deliberate act to disadvantage borrowers.
Final Verdict: Misleading Headline and Overstated Claims
While the article correctly reports that student loan repayment applications were temporarily halted, it lacks clarification that this was in response to a court order regarding the SAVE plan. Additionally, framing the move as a broad political action by the Trump administration oversimplifies a complex legal situation. This results in a misleading impression that all repayment plans were permanently shut down.
Stay Informed with DBUNK
Misinformation spreads fast. Ensure you have the facts. Download the DBUNK app today to verify news in real time and avoid misleading narratives.
Read the original article here.
