Did X Settle with Trump to Avoid an Appeal?
The claim that X (formerly Twitter) settled a lawsuit with Donald Trump for $10 million has sparked widespread curiosity, particularly due to the previous dismissal of the lawsuit by a federal court. This fact-check investigates whether any missing context or misinformation surrounds this settlement.
Historical Context of Trump’s Twitter Ban
Donald Trump was permanently banned from Twitter on January 8, 2021, following the U.S. Capitol attack. Twitter cited concerns about further incitement of violence. In 2022, Elon Musk acquired Twitter and reinstated Trump’s account. The legal battle over this suspension escalated when Trump sued the platform for violating his First Amendment rights, though a federal judge dismissed the lawsuit.
Breaking Down the Settlement
Claim #1: X settled a lawsuit for $10 million over Trump’s Twitter suspension
The article states that X will pay Trump $10 million to resolve the lawsuit. Settlements often occur to avoid prolonged legal battles and additional expenses, but this does not necessarily indicate an admission of wrongdoing. However, no official statement from X has been provided confirming the reasoning behind the decision.
Claim #2: Trump’s lawsuit was dismissed, so an appeal was the only remaining legal action
The article correctly states that Trump’s lawsuit was initially dismissed by a U.S. district judge. However, the article omits details about the status of the appeals process. While CBS News reports the appeal was “still pending,” public court records of the appeal are not cited, leaving some uncertainty as to whether X anticipated an unfavorable ruling.
Claim #3: Musk currently works for the Trump administration
The article claims that Musk heads a department within Trump’s administration and serves as a special government employee. There is no publicly available confirmation of Musk holding an official government position in such a department. This appears to be a significant factual error requiring clarification.
Final Verdict on the Article’s Accuracy
The CBS News article is largely factual but presents some missing context and potential misinformation. While the settlement with Trump is real, the article lacks details regarding the legal standing of Trump’s appeal. Additionally, the statement that Musk holds a government position under Trump appears unverified and misleading.
Stay Informed with DBUNK
Want to make sure you’re getting the full picture? Download DBUNK now to fact-check news and avoid misinformation.
